Is it all in the picture?
Earlier today the US Immigration and Customs Enforcement released a statement saying that they had found a member of the El Salvadorian gang MS-13. They stated that the gentleman, who goes by the name Cesar Amauri Cruz-Martin, was flown to Louisiana to be deported to El Salvador to be charged with murder. In December of 2009, Cesar shot and killed three men before he fled El Salvador to head to the United States. They did release one photograph of this gentleman to the press as well. The below picture is of Cesar arriving in Louisiana:
Source: http://www.nola.com/crime/index.ssf/2015/09/el_salvador_gang_member_murder.html
As per the usual at the Photog Mama blog you may be asking what does this have to do with photography? Well, actually a lot!
When you look at the above photograph with the back story that I gave you what do you think? Perhaps you are thinking "he is a brutal killer" or "He is disgusting being a part of a gang!" or "He looks the part". When we see a photograph we often think of the old saying, "A picture is worth 1,000 words". I know that I often do, and this photo is worth some words.... but are the words the truth? An exaggeration? A memory? A document?
In the world of photography, we all encounter many burning questions at some point, and one of the biggest questions is... Is this picture telling me the truth? There is not always an easy answer to this question, though. For instance, the photo above shows Cesar arriving at the airport, he is talking to an officer, he looks tough and upset. All of these statements I think are the truth. Are we missing some truth, though?
Think about it... maybe not focus on this gentleman, but think about what is happening in El Salvador right now. We have all seen news reports about how it is the murder capital of the world. With an estimated 70,000 men involved in gang activity and 4,000 murders this year, El Salvador is a place that anyone may wish to flee from. How do these men get caught up in this gang activity? Where are people like Cesar sent when they are put in prison? What are their families like?
As photographers, we need to consider these angles as we take our photos. Is our intention to come across as truthful? Do we wish to know more about a subject than just the base facts like the article above?
One such photographer goes by the name of Adam Hinton. Adam initially set out to interview and photograph the families in the slums of El Salvador. He went with the intention of avoiding the MS-13 gang for he had heard that they are brutal, uncaring, and disturbed people. As he began to interview their families he noticed that there was rarely a family that was not touched in some way by the MS-13 gang members. The big difference though is he came away with stories about how these members keep the slums safe from rival gangs and even police brutality. The families appreciated these men and saw them simply as men doing what they needed to do for those they love.
This gave Adam an idea... an idea that would lead him to the truth about people like Cesar. He decided to find a way to get into Penal de Ciudad Barrios, THE most brutal prison in El Salvador. It is so dangerous behind the prison doors that even guards refuse to enter. Penal de Ciudad Barrios has turned into a town run by 26,000 inmates. The prison was originally built for 800 prisoners, but the brutality and crime that is happening in the country has led to the prison becoming grossly overcrowded.
After a few years, Adam gained entry for three hours! The truth began to hit the camera. Adam said of the experience, "When I met the gang members, they chilled out straightaway and acted normally – in the prison they’re probably safer than they will be anywhere else in the world". He was able to get truth telling photos that tell stories about the inmates. Their worn faces and tattoos tell stories of loved ones, battles never won, friends lost and hopes that will never be fulfilled. Many of the men talked about their families. They also talked about how they were working on opening a hospital within the compound so that care would be available to the inmates. They also spoke of an interest in the arts and how they wanted to have a space to express their artistic interests.
After telling you all of this I would like you to see one of Adam's photos below:
Source: © Adam Hinton / Panos http://www.bjp-online.com/2015/09/adam-hinton-ms-13/
Now that you have seen this gentleman I would like you to look at the first photo of Cesar. What story do you see in this face? You may not be able to forgive his crimes, even though you do not know them, but do you see the human being? What is this photograph telling you? Does it feel more real?
The works of Adam are brutally truthful. The soul piercing looks that these men give the camera are amazing! To me, this is truth reported in a way that I could only hope for in my photos!
This week's challenge everyone is to take a look at what you are photographing. Is there a story in your photograph? Is there truth there? Show your photo to another person what do they see in the photo?
The next time that you see a news article take a look at the picture provided and see if there may be truth there that you do not know about. You may surprise yourself by what you see!
I hope that you all have a great week! This Photog Mama is off the shoot some truth! :)
Note: Adam Hinton's photo book titled MS-13 will be released later this month!
Sources
Cox, Thomas. (2015) Portraits of gang members in El Salvadorian prison too dangerous for the wardens to enter. Retrieved from: http://www.bjp-online.com/2015/09/adam-hinton-ms-13/
Lane, Emily. (2015) Alleged gang member deported to El Salvador to face multiple murder charges. Retrieved from: http://www.nola.com/crime/index.ssf/2015/09/el_salvador_gang_member_murder.html


Anu,
ReplyDeleteWhat a great post! I love how you combined both photography and the recent news! Doing research on the topic really made your post come to life! As usual, GREAT JOB!
Can't wait to read what you come up with next!
Jessica
Thank you Jessica! I must admit it took me a bit to form an idea that would tie into photography, but I was determined. This class has been fun and challenging for blogging! I have really liked your blog posts as well. They are always so personal!
DeleteI hope that you have a great day!
Anu
I really enjoy reading your blogs, they are so interesting and i love that you always manage to incorporate photography back to it.
ReplyDeleteLogan,
DeleteThank you for your compliment! This class has been a challenge to tie things back into my blogs over all subject, but to tell you the truth it has really strengthened my writing this semester, so I am very happy about that! Thank you so much for your feedback!
I hope that you have a great week!
Anu
Very powerful write-up! As usual, you have some great, thought provoking content! As a fellow photographer I appreciate what you are saying about the power of photographs and their ability to create, or even change someone's perception of a person, event, place, etc.
ReplyDeleteAwesome!
Thank you Professor Block! It took me a while to think of a compelling post, but I am finding that my writing has much improved with these projects. Thank you so much for your feedback. It helps to hear from fellow photographers!
DeleteAnu